Dickinson

Hailee Steinfeld

Emily Dickinson

Toby Huss

Edward Dickinson

Adrian Enscoe

Austin Dickinson

Anna Baryshnikov

Lavinia 'Vinnie' Dickinson

Ella Hunt

Sue Gilbert

Jane Krakowski

Mrs. Dickinson

Chinaza Uche

Henry

Sophie Zucker

Abby Wood

Kevin Yee

Toshiaki

Gus Birney

Jane Humphrey

Allegra Heart

Abiah Root

Darlene Hunt

Maggie

Amanda Warren

Betty

Samuel Farnsworth

George Gould

Finn Jones

Samuel Bowles

Robert Picardo

Ithamar Conkey

Pico Alexander

Henry 'Ship' Shipley

Erin Gerasimovich

Anna

Neville Lee

Clara

Will Pullen

Nobody

Gabriel Ebert

Thomas Wentworth Higginson

Ayo Edebiri

Hattie

Wiz Khalifa

Death

Nore Davis

Solomon

Myles Alexander Evans

Erasmus

Tristan Griffin

Everett

Wavyy Jonez

The Wall

Curt Morlaye

Michael River Jordan

Gus Halper

Joseph Lyman

Matt Lauria

Ben Newton

Joey Odom

Archibald

Max Chernin

Samuel Strong

Jessica Hecht

Aunt Lavinia

Jamel Davall Rodriguez

Freddie

Levi Ricks

Helen

Jason Mantzoukas

Bee (voice)

Warren Katz

Minister

Teddy Bergman

Minister

Merritt Chase

Union Officer (uncredited)

John Mulaney

Henry David Thoreau

Ade Otukoya

Henry 'Box' Brown

Justine Rappaport

Puppeteer

Zosia Mamet

Louisa May Alcott

Ziwe

Sojourner Truth

James Urbaniak

Ophthalmologist

Emilio Oliveira

Loud Man

Anna O'Donoghue

Loud Woman

Brendan Hayes

Dishwasher Vendor

Olivia Khoshatefeh

Young Woman #1

Manuela Sosa

Young Woman #2

Timothy Simons

Frederick Law Olmsted

Jibz Cameron

Sanford Robinson Gifford

Kelli Barrett

Adelaide May

Curtis Bannister

Opera Chorus Member 1

Lindsay Nicole Chambers

Opera Chorus Member 2

Ron Crawford

Usher

Jen Ponton

Body Healer

Nick Kroll

Edgar Allan Poe

Omar Shaukat

Townie 1

Tim Simon

Townie 2

Braeden Brickner

Newspaper Boy

Tatiana Marie Barber

Activist / Dancer

Anthony Auguste

Dancer

Kenny Bermudez

Dancer

Chloe Campbell

Dancer

Shawn Alynda Fisher

Dancer

Marquis Floyd

Dancer

Antonio Harvey

Dancer

Marley Lubin

Dancer

Nerita McFarlane

Dancer

Bethany Puente

Dancer

Wade Watson

Dancer

Imani Wisdom

Dancer

Damani Van Rensalier

Dancer

Marié Botha

Mary Bowles

Brendan Dalton

Sylvester

David Manis

Minister

Roland Sands

Old Man

Dewight Braxton Jr.

Soldier

Billy Eichner

Walt Whitman

Beth Ditto

Pfaff's Dancer

James Michael Lambert

Bloody Stump

Anthony R. Mottola

Wounded Soldier

Mariah Naomi Sanchez

Nurse

Wale Adebiyi

Orderly

Emily Kramm

Pfaff's Dancer #1

Markcus Blair

Pfaff's Dancer #2

Julio Rey

Pfaff's Dancer #3

Daphne Kinard

Pfaff's Dancer #4

Zo Tipp

Pfaff's Dancer #5

Gabriel Hyman

Pfaff's Dancer #6

Tómas Matos

Pfaff's Dancer #7

Emily Dorsch

Auctioneer

Nandita Shenoy

Woman

Bex Odorisio

Woman 1

Ryah Nixon

Woman 2

David Michael Garry

Man in Crowd

Jordan Bellow

Soldier #2

Jordan Lage

Asylum Head Doctor

Marceline Hugot

Asylum Patient

Annie Hamilton

Florence

Morgan Sullivan

Soldier

Casey Jane Ellison

Doll Woman

Sibyl Santiago

Nurse

Alexio Barboza

Dancer

Chloe Fineman

Sylvia Plath

Tuck Sweeney

Irish Man / Bartender

Mirella Cardoso

Mermaid #1

Imani Pearl Williams

Mermaid #2

Chinara Stroman

Mermaid #3

Kathy Liu

Mermaid #4

Natalie Von Kirk

Mermaid #5

Jeremy Lawrence

Professor Hitchcock

James Dwyer

Prefect

Peggy Cosgrave

Mrs. Thoreau

Abra Tabak

Thoreau's Sister

Vince Edgehill

Conductor

Lucas Near-Verbrugghe

James

Michael Braun

Thomas Elliott Moody

Peter Maloney

Doctor Brewster

John Leonard Thompson

Mr. Humphrey

Dee Hoty

Mrs. Humphrey

Andre Urban

Sailor

Jason Williams

Dancer

Dasha Nekrasova

Ellen Mandeville Grout